- Lead
- 1. Why these four filters
- 2. The five
- 3. Snapshot (4WD + ventilation)
- 4. Size — parking vs cabin
- 5. “4WD” is not one system
- 6. Fuel — 4WD vs 4WD
- 7. Seat ventilation — can it coexist with 4WD?
- 8. Price — entry with 4WD + ventilation
- 9. One by one — who each car is for
- 10. Near-misses (cut from the list)
- 11. Hypothesis before test drives
- Summary
Lead
Hi, I’m Pomarano.
This Daily post is about shopping for an SUV. Two models were locked in from the start: the Mazda CX-5 and the Toyota Corolla Cross. I added three more in a similar price range so I could line up five side by side.
The four filters:
- Not too big
- Good fuel economy
- 4WD (including AWD / E-Four; every comparison is 4WD)
- Seat ventilation (front seats; standard vs option below)
The fourth one is surprisingly strict. Plenty of popular SUVs in this budget skip ventilated seats. Adding 4WD also rules out the cheapest 2WD trims. This is a pre-test-drive note — I have not picked a winner yet. Prices and fuel figures are manufacturer suggested retail (tax included) and WLTC, as of August 2026. Grade and options change the numbers.
- Japanese version: here
1. Why these four filters
Daily driving means parking and fuel matter. I also want 4WD for rain, snow, and wet roads. Japanese summers make a sweaty back hard to ignore. Seat heaters are common; ventilated seats that move air are a different option.
| Filter | How I use it here |
|---|---|
| Size | Length around 4.7 m or less. Larger than Harrier-class is out |
| Fuel | Catalog WLTC, 4WD specs only. Strong hybrid vs mild hybrid kept separate |
| 4WD | Badges say 4WD / AWD / E-Four. I treat them as 4WD for the shortlist |
| Seat ventilation | Front seats. Prefer standard. Call out options |
| Price band | Body price for 4WD + ventilation: roughly ¥3.60–4.90 million |
Once you insist on ventilated 4WD, the list shrinks fast. Vezel, ZR-V, and Crosstrek are appealing on size and fuel, but Japan-spec models have no front seat ventilation, so they are out of the five. I mention them later as near-misses.
2. The five
Two locked, three added.
| # | Model | Why it is in |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mazda CX-5 (2026) | Original pick. New L grade has ventilation standard, plus 4WD |
| 2 | Toyota Corolla Cross | Original pick. Z has ventilation standard, plus E-Four |
| 3 | Mazda CX-30 | Smallest of the five. 25L line gets ventilation + 4WD |
| 4 | Subaru Forester | AWD standard. S:HEV improved fuel. Ventilation is optional |
| 5 | Toyota RAV4 (from Dec 2025) | HEV Z is E-Four. Ventilation standard |
I compare grades that have both 4WD and ventilation. Cheapest 2WD trims do not meet the brief. CX-30 2.0-liter grades are 2WD-only, so choosing 4WD naturally means the 25L line.
3. Snapshot (4WD + ventilation)
Fuel is WLTC combined. Prices are tax-included MSRP. Every row is 4WD.
| Model | Grade I look at | Drive | L × W × H | Fuel (approx.) | Ventilation | Price (approx.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CX-5 | L 4WD | i-ACTIV AWD | 4,690 × 1,860 × 1,695 mm | 14.2 km/L (MHEV) | Standard | ¥4.3065 million |
| Corolla Cross | Hybrid Z E-Four | E-Four | 4,455 × 1,825 × 1,620 mm | 24.6 km/L | Standard | ¥3.689 million |
| CX-30 | 25L 4WD | i-ACTIV AWD | 4,395 × 1,795 × 1,540 mm | 14.5 km/L (MHEV) | Standard | ¥3.6465 million |
| Forester | Premium S:HEV | Full-time AWD | 4,655 × 1,830 × 1,730 mm | ~18.4 km/L | Option (leather pack) | ¥4.48 million~ + OP |
| RAV4 | HEV Z | E-Four | 4,600 × 1,855 × 1,680 mm | 22.5 km/L | Standard | ¥4.90 million |
Versus cheapest 2WD, Corolla Cross, CX-30, and CX-5 add about ¥230,000–260,000. Forester and RAV4 HEV are 4WD (AWD / E-Four) from the start — there is no 2WD escape hatch.
flowchart LR S["Smaller / cheaper / efficient"] M["Middle"] L["Roomier / pricier"] A["CX-30"] B["Corolla Cross"] C["RAV4 / Forester"] D["CX-5"] S --> A S --> B M --> C L --> D classDef small fill:#e8f5e9,stroke:#2e7d32,stroke-width:2px,color:#1a1a1a classDef mid fill:#fff3e0,stroke:#ef6c00,stroke-width:2px,color:#1a1a1a classDef large fill:#e8f4fc,stroke:#3d7ea6,stroke-width:2px,color:#1a1a1a class A,B small class C mid class D large
If “not too big” is strict, the new CX-5 is 4,690 mm — longest of the five. Comparing it to the previous CX-5 in your head may make it feel a size up.
4. Size — parking vs cabin
By length:
| Rank (shortest) | Model | Length | Turning radius (approx.) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | CX-30 | 4,395 mm | ~5.3 m |
| 2 | Corolla Cross | 4,455 mm | 5.2 m |
| 3 | RAV4 HEV Z | 4,600 mm | 5.7 m |
| 4 | Forester | 4,655 mm | 5.4 m |
| 5 | CX-5 | 4,690 mm | 5.6 m |
Tight lots and multi-storey parks: CX-30 and Corolla Cross are easier. CX-30 is also the narrowest at 1,795 mm.
Rear seat and cargo go the other way. CX-5, Forester, and RAV4 have more room for trips and luggage. Corolla Cross cargo is usable, but not CX-5 spacious. CX-30 is a compact crossover — rear seat and boot need a compromise.
For my use: short cars if daily parking wins; CX-5 / Forester / RAV4 if weekend cargo and rear passengers win. Length barely changes with 4WD.
5. “4WD” is not one system
The filter is 4WD, but the hardware differs. Snow confidence does not rank on a spreadsheet.
| Models | Badge | Character |
|---|---|---|
| Forester | Symmetrical AWD | Full-time all-wheel drive. Most serious for snow / rough roads |
| Corolla Cross / RAV4 | E-Four | Rear axle is a motor. Fuel on pavement, plus help when you start to slip |
| CX-5 / CX-30 | i-ACTIV AWD | Sends drive rearward as needed. Mazda’s “connected to the road” pitch |
Forester does not “add 4WD” — AWD is the only layout. Corolla Cross and RAV4 E-Four keep catalog fuel closer to 2WD while still meeting the 4WD filter. Mazda still sells 2WD; this post sticks to 4WD.
I am not shopping for serious off-road. Rain, snow, and mountain roads — does the rear axle work — is the question.
6. Fuel — 4WD vs 4WD
Catalog gaps are clear. All figures are 4WD.
| Model | Powertrain | WLTC (4WD) |
|---|---|---|
| Corolla Cross | Strong hybrid | 24.6 km/L (Z E-Four) |
| RAV4 | Strong hybrid | 22.5 km/L (HEV Z E-Four) |
| Forester | Strong hybrid (S:HEV) | ~18.4 km/L |
| CX-30 | Mild hybrid | 14.5 km/L (25L 4WD) |
| CX-5 | Mild hybrid | 14.2 km/L (L 4WD) |
Corolla Cross drops from 26.4 km/L in 2WD and still leads. Holding 24 km/L-class on E-Four is the headline. RAV4’s strong-hybrid E-Four is strong for the size.
CX-5 and CX-30 mild-hybrid 4WD fall to the 14 km/L range. If you pick Mazda for ride and cabin, fuel is something you accept. Forester S:HEV sits in the middle: ~18 km/L with full-time AWD is respectable.
Real-world numbers move with A/C in summer and short trips. Over high annual mileage, Corolla Cross and RAV4 hybrids still win.
7. Seat ventilation — can it coexist with 4WD?
This filter did the most work. Adding 4WD does not change how ventilation is offered.
| Model | How you get it | With 4WD |
|---|---|---|
| Corolla Cross | Front standard on Z | Z E-Four has both. G / S do not |
| CX-5 | Front standard on L | L 4WD has both. S / G do not |
| CX-30 | Front standard on 25L / 25 Air Edition | 4WD is 25L-line only. 2.0L is 2WD-only |
| RAV4 | Front standard on HEV Z | HEV Z is E-Four. Adventure has no ventilation |
| Forester | Option on Premium (leather pack) | AWD is standard; ventilation is extra |
Entry to 4WD + ventilation: CX-30 25L 4WD (¥3.6465 million) and Corolla Cross Z E-Four (¥3.689 million) sit together. CX-5 L 4WD is ¥4.3065 million; RAV4 HEV Z is ¥4.90 million at the top.
Forester’s always-on AWD is a plus; ventilation is still an option. I keep it in the “has it” column, but it is not standard like the other four.
8. Price — entry with 4WD + ventilation
Body price only, lowest trim that meets the filters.
| Cheapest first | Model | 4WD price |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | CX-30 25L 4WD | ¥3.6465 million |
| 2 | Corolla Cross HV Z E-Four | ¥3.689 million |
| 3 | CX-5 L 4WD | ¥4.3065 million |
| 4 | Forester Premium S:HEV | ¥4.48 million (+ leather OP) |
| 5 | RAV4 HEV Z E-Four | ¥4.90 million |
Fees, paint, and nav push the quote up. Corolla Cross and CX-30 clear 4WD + ventilation in the ¥3.6 million range. CX-5 is cabin and finish around ¥4.3 million. RAV4 is the step-up hybrid SUV at ¥4.90 million.
Corolla Cross Z 2WD is ¥3.43 million — out of scope here. Discounts and residual-value loans are dealer-specific, so this post stays on MSRP.
9. One by one — who each car is for
9-1. Mazda CX-5 (L 4WD)
Cabin and equipment are thick on the new model. L includes leather and front ventilation. 4WD is ¥4.3065 million. Best if ride and interior satisfaction come first.
Weak points: fuel and size. 4,690 mm long, 5.6 m turning circle — tight parks will notice. Mild-hybrid 4WD at 14.2 km/L is a long way from Corolla Cross.
9-2. Toyota Corolla Cross (Hybrid Z E-Four)
Best balance of fuel, price, ventilation, and maneuverability. Z E-Four hits all four filters at ¥3.689 million. WLTC 24.6 km/L leads the five.
Cabin and cargo are enough, not CX-5 / RAV4 roomy. E-Four is a rear motor, not Forester full-time AWD. If ride quality is the top priority, a test drive may feel thin.
9-3. Mazda CX-30 (25L 4WD)
Smallest of the five; 1,795 mm wide is easy in town. 4WD exists only on the 25L line, so ventilation and 4WD land on the same grades. Entry ¥3.6465 million is the cheapest of the five.
Weak points: rear seat, cargo, no strong hybrid. 4WD fuel is 14.5 km/L, similar to CX-5, well behind Corolla Cross.
9-4. Subaru Forester (Premium S:HEV)
Full-time AWD is standard — strongest of the five for snow and rough roads. S:HEV into the 18 km/L range makes it easier to choose than older Foresters. Cabin height should make getting in and out easy.
Ventilation as an option and a ¥4.48 million start are the hurdles. Add the leather pack and it often costs more than CX-5 L 4WD.
9-5. Toyota RAV4 (HEV Z E-Four)
For people who need more space than Corolla Cross but still want strong-hybrid fuel (22.5 km/L). HEV Z is E-Four with front ventilation standard. At 4,600 mm it is shorter than the CX-5 — mid-pack among the five.
¥4.90 million is the ceiling. Adventure is ¥4.50 million without ventilation. Cutting budget means dropping a filter.
10. Near-misses (cut from the list)
Popular cars that fail at least one of the four filters:
| Model | Why it is out |
|---|---|
| Honda Vezel | 4WD exists; no front ventilation |
| Honda ZR-V | e:HEV 4WD fuel is good; no front ventilation |
| Subaru Crosstrek | AWD standard, S:HEV available; no front ventilation |
| Nissan X-Trail | e-4ORCE is appealing; too long, no ventilation |
| Mitsubishi Eclipse Cross | 4WD exists; no ventilation |
If summer comfort is heaters-only, these can come back. For me, dropping ventilation or 4WD makes the brief too loose, so they stay out.
11. Hypothesis before test drives
I have not driven them yet. All comparisons are 4WD.
| If I prioritize… | Tentative first pick |
|---|---|
| Fuel, price, parking | Corolla Cross Z E-Four |
| Small size + Mazda ride | CX-30 25L 4WD |
| Cabin quality and kit | CX-5 L 4WD |
| Snow / full-time AWD | Forester Premium S:HEV |
| Space + hybrid fuel | RAV4 HEV Z E-Four |
Daily shortlist for now: Corolla Cross Z E-Four and CX-30 25L 4WD (both around ¥3.6 million). Wider cabin comparison: CX-5 L 4WD. If budget allows: RAV4 HEV Z. If snow is the story: Forester.
Next: sit in dealers with the same brief (4WD + front ventilation), check rear seat, cargo, visibility, and turning. Catalogs will not tell me how strong the seat fans are, how wide the car feels in a tight lot, or how the 4WD actually behaves.
Summary
- Anchors: CX-5 and Corolla Cross. Filters (not too big, fuel, 4WD, seat ventilation) added CX-30 / Forester / RAV4
- Every comparison is 4WD. Cheapest 2WD does not qualify
- 4WD + ventilation knocks out many popular SUVs in this budget
- Parking and fuel: Corolla Cross Z E-Four. Smallest: CX-30 25L 4WD. Cabin: CX-5 L 4WD
- Forester: full-time AWD and S:HEV are strong; ventilation is optional
- RAV4 HEV Z: E-Four fuel and size are balanced; it is the most expensive of the five
- Pre-drive notes. Prices and fuel as of August 2026
I plan to add how the cars felt versus the catalog after I drive them.
コメント